New York Pizza & Pints

We were in town for a basketball tournament…. Showed up with quite a crowd for them on a Friday night. Couldn’t be happier with the service. They were understaffed, but everyone still kept a smile on their face. Scott took care of us through a few order delays. Appreciated the honesty and integrity they had with letting us know they were a bit overwhelmed. Food was fantastic and worth the wait.

This place is a hidden gem!! Management was reaching out to one of their customers but had my phone number by mistake. After talking to the Scott over the phone, I realized his restaurant was close to where I lived. Since we were relatively close, he invited me to the store to try some items from their menu AND OH MY GOSH…

We arrived and walked inside. As we were admiring the interior design and the quality of all the interior details, we were promptly greeted by two young ladies at the counter. We advised them that we had never been there before and asked for some recommendations. We ended up getting a Cheese Slice, Pepperoni Slice and even got a little wild and tried their Meatball Mozzarella Sandwich from their East Coast Sandwiches section. By the way, they have Topo Chico Hard Seltzer’s that are pretty good too. The pizzas were great but the Meatball Mozzarella blew me away! Everything was so fresh and unique. We ended up taking half a pizza home along with the other half of my sandwich (for lunch tomorrow).

If you’re still reading this review, you should just put New York Pizza & Pints on “the list” of places to take your family for dinner. They have plenty of tables that seat 6 adults comfortably. Thank you for inviting us Scott! We will be back with friends and family soon:)