Sheepshead Baygels

Their sfogliatella are a yummy weekend treat!
Friendly staff and great service. Must try the make your own omelette with potatoes. Family run business with a very personal feel. I would buy here rather than the chains. This is my local go to breakfast place. However...its cash only. I wish they accepted credit card. I understand the fee is too much but maybe Dan Price can help?

this place is amazing!! we just moved to this area from brooklyn and came here twice in the first week. they have a great selection of options. we’ve so far just gotten bagel sandwiches which have been the bomb. the staff is very friendly and pleasant to talk to.

I love how the bagels are soft and doughy on the inside and crispy on the outside. My only complaint is that they have the French toast bagels next to the regular bagels which made my bagel taste sweet

I have been searching for a better bagel for 6 years, and I simply cannot find any!!! The crisp outside and the soft inside is unprecedented by any other bagel shop in Monmouth county. I would rank this as the best bagel, but second best bagel shop. I think they could be a big more generous with their bagel sandwiches, sometimes there is hardly any meat, but regardless, the bagel carries most of the weight. I would recommend this place 11 times out of 10.

Honestly the best service and best bagels I’ve had in a long time. We come all the way from upstate New York to get these bagels. They taste just like they are from Brooklyn! So good! If you haven’t had the French toast bagels, you HAVE TO HAVE THEM! They are AMAZING! Will always go back! It’s cash only so make sure you have it. They even give you a bakers dozen!