Sullivan & Mattheiss

(4 Reviews)

101 Vose Ave, South Orange, NJ 07079

Contact and Address

Brant Pflum

(November 21, 2022, 5:09 pm)
Have worked with Holly for years. Very knowledgeable helping clients find the right insurance policy.
Dennis McCalahan

(November 19, 2022, 8:11 am)
Dave and Holly are the absolute best. Not only do they work their hardest to get you the best rates, they take an interest in what coverage you’re getting to ensure you’re happy with the price while being fully aware of what you are (or are not) getting.

The relationship they built with me gave me peace of mind and confidence that I won’t have to look elsewhere when my policies come up each year.
Jimmy Colborn

(November 17, 2022, 5:09 pm)
Fantastic company, coverages, and prices! Highly recommend!
Sandra Lakey

(November 11, 2022, 6:55 pm)
Several years ago, after a bad experience with an insurance agent, I found Holly and Dave Gardner in Winfield, MO. They are conveniently located and always available. In July, on a late Friday afternoon, I was in a very scary accident at Mark Twain Lake. After calling 911, my next call was Safe Harbor because I couldn't find my insurance card. I was very upset and they calmed me down and drove back to the office to get the information I needed! Not only that, Dave called to check on me during the weekend. I can't thank them enough! If you are looking for a caring, honest insurance agency, please give Safe Harbor a call!

The phone number for Sullivan & Mattheiss is (973) 275-1800.

Sullivan & Mattheiss is located at 101 Vose Ave, South Orange, NJ 07079

The website (URL) for Sullivan & Mattheiss is: https://www.sullmattpclaw.com/