Which Wich Settlers Market

First time me and wife had eaten at one of your places. We were very happy with the food and the service. Next time we are in Williamsburg we will stop by again. I like your look and feel. Great job! Thanks!

I come here at least once per week. The music they play and the overall atmosphere are phenomenal. The only thing better than those are the sandwiches, I’ve had everything on the menu and all of it is incredible. If you really want to treat yourself get your cookie warmed. The staff are always incredibly pleasant and greet me every time I come in. This is my go to whenever I want food, if I could I’d give more than 5 stars. I come every Wednesday, and it’s usually the same crew working. Brendon, Angelina and Meredith feel like a second set of parents to me with the way they take care of me, honestly I wish I could give them all a raise. My friends and I joke that I could just live at this which wich and eat all of my meals there. It’s like a second home.

This is a pretty frequent spot for me and my friends, and it’s a great place. Starting with the service, the staff are always amazing and incredibly kind. Big shoutout to Angelina who is always giving us our sandwiches with a huge smile! The food is incredible, I usually go for the Club Which or the Buffalo Chicken. I also highly recommend the fries, which are cooked right in front of you when you order them, never old and soggy like other places. Will continue to frequent this spot.

My family and I were on vacation from New Jersey and unknowingly walked in 5 minutes before closing. When we realized what time it was we walked out back to car. Before I could get my seatbelt on, Cody came out of the store and to our car and said that he would be more than happy to make us some food regardless of the time. So we went back into the store and Cody and Connor proceeded to provide the best customer service possible. We had never been to one of these restaurants before so the ordering process was explained. Even while making our sandwiches both Cody and Connor were interacting with us and making the whole experience something to remember. The food was excellent, the service was better. You should be proud to have Cody and Connor on your staff representing your company. 5 stars, would put 10 if it was an option.

Lots of options and clean restaurant. It was nothing special though and nothing I would come back for. Average sandwiches and pretty pricey for what you get.